Darwin's Black Box

A detailed Summary of Darwin's Black Box

Dr. H. Allen Orr is a Professor of Biology at University of Rochester who studies the genetic changes underlying evolution. He is particularly interested in the genetics of speciation and the genetics of adaptation. Allen Orr wrote an article criticizing Michael Behe saying °The latest attack on evolution is cleverly argued, biologically informed ¨C and wrong.± Before starting out with his argument Orr admits that Behe¯s book is after all a creationist¯s¯ dream come true, and that no one can deny Behe¯s grasp of biochemistry. Orr says, unlike a few previous biologists who have taken aim at Darwin, Behe is the real thing, even though he tries to prove Behe wrong. What¯s different about Behe from his less-sophisticated brethren, according to Orr, is that Behe does not deny evolution. Orr takes Behe seriously; hence this is the reason why he wrote the article.

Orr is interested why Behe feels he is especially qualified to critique Darwinism. He says to a historian or an electrician Behe certainly looks qualified since he is a °Biologist±. But it is not that simple. By turning the table around Orr starts a new argument saying °If I, an evolutionary biologist, were to announce that biochemistry is deeply flawed ¨C I¯ve shown fo

I admit that may be there are some good arguments against Behe¯s book and his theory that prove Behe wrong, but the bottom line is I have searched through many-many articles and did not find something convincing. I am not a true religious person, but I believe that when a real biochemist such as Michel Behe proves and shows that existence of some sort of a intelligent input c¤ God in this case c¤ then I believe in the existence of God.

r instance, that enzymes are not catalysts ¨C I doubt I¯d get a listen. I surely wouldn¯t get a publisher. Why is everyone an expert witness when the topic is Darwinism but not when it¯s biochemistry?±

The answer is complicated, but a few things are clear. First, Darwinism matters. Many people will inevitably have questions about Darwinism because many people will inevitably think about it. Secondly, this has more to do with our education system at American Universities where there is a striking asymmetry in molecular versus evolutionary education. Although many science and all biology students are required to endure molecular courses, but even an introductory evolution class is often an elective. Consequently, many professional scientists know surprisingly little about evolution.

Later on in his article Orr brings out the example of the heart. The human heart is built of a pump and valves. Remove either one

Some common words found in the essay are:
American Universities, Behe Behe, Orr Behe, Similarly Orr, Allen Orr, Michael Behe, Michel Behe, University Rochester, Darwin Behe, What¯s Behe, article orr, behe¯s book, prove behe wrong, irreducibly complex, behe wrong, computer programming, irreducible complexity, prove behe, allen orr, orr behe, wrote article,

Approximate Word count = 915
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)

Category: Science