naturalsm vs realism
Naturalism is an offshoot of realism. Although they are related, they are indeed different. Naturalism presents a deterministic view of man's life and actions, while realism is the way things appear or might appear to be. We see examples of naturalism in Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" and also in his short story, "The Blue Hotel". "The Blue Hotel" is a story of three men who arrived at a hotel during a snowstorm. Mr. Scully, the owner, and his son Johnnie gladly accepted the men into the hotel. The men sat down to a game of cards with Johnnie and all was going well until one of the newcomers, a Swedish man, began to panic. He stood up and began saying that someone had died in the room that they had been in, and that he too will die in that very room. The other men looked at him as if he were crazy, yet he continued to cry out that he must leave before he gets killed. This man was determined that his fate was death in this house and had almost gone mad. That is when Scully came into the room, brought the Swede upstairs, gave him a drink, and calmed him down. When the Swede returned downstairs he was a completely different person. For he was afraid of the Westerners before he went up as he believed them to be bad and da
ngerous men, yet this was not the case upon his return. He now had no fear and his whole attitude changed. He demanded the men to play another round of cards and as he played he adopted the well hated fashion of board whacking. During the game he got up and yelled, "you are cheatin" at Johnnie. Johnnie denied this accusation and it caused the two men to go outside and fight. The Swede's actions were now out of control. Even if the man was cheating, there was no reason to fight. But the Swede beat Johnnie regardless and left the hotel. His leaving the hotel brought him to a saloon. Once in the saloon, he again returned to his rude ways. He was getting loud in the saloon and the bar keeper asked him to shush, but that just angered the Swede. He demanded that people will drink with him in celebration of his fight with Johnnie and scorned the barkeeper for trying to shush him. When no one would drink with him he grew angry and grabbed a small man by the throat. This proved to be a fatal mistake for the Swede, because the small man stabbed him to death. As we see how the man's actions in "The Blue Hotel" have caused a man his life, we see the opposite affect in "The Open Boat". This short story begins with four men in a small life boat after their steamer, the Commodore, had been sunk. The men were stuck out in the dingy miles from shore and they must row there way back in to safety. There was a captain on the boat who guided the men, the correspond
Some common words found in the essay are:
Blue Hotel, Johnnie Johnnie, , blue hotel, Crane's Boat, boat short story, life boat, swede's actions, caused life, stabbed death, short story, boat short,
Approximate Word count = 994
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)
|