Innate Ideas
In this paper I will discuss the Descartes vs Locke debate on innate ideas, also giving insight on what an innate idea means. Each philosopher takes a very different stand on the issue and each point of view will be thoroughly examined. The main question at hand here is, where do our ideas come from? The controversy and basis of the argument is that some philosophers and others believe that human beings have innate knowledge or ideas. The others deny it. What seems to be black and white turns grey when one asks, what is it to have innate knowledge or an innate idea? Therefore, when analyzing the debate over innateness, we must look at what we mean if we say someone knows something or has ideas innately (Stich 1). For the purpose of understanding, we can look back on historical caveats. Plato, for example, seemed to believe that all knowledge is innate. The problem with Plato's view is, only part of what we think we know, is known innately (2). Plato does not try to enlarge the concept of innateness to cover all knowledge, but rather he tried to minimize the concept until it fits what we know innately. According to Webster's dictionary, innate means existing in
said we get our ideas from experience. Stich, Stephen, ed. Innate Ideas. Berleley and Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press, 1975. 71-86. Nevertheless, Descartes holds that "all our ideas are innate in us in the sense that we are born, not with a capacity to receive them from the outside, but with a power to form each of them without sensible qualities which it is capable of having (77). o an individual from birth, or, belonging to the essential nature of something. When trying to define innateness, Descartes says he is using it in the same sense of the word as when we say certain diseases are innate. So what does it mean to have an innate disease? A disease is prefaced with a unique set of symptoms. Therefore, there is a relationship between symptoms and the disease itself.
Some common words found in the essay are:
According Webster's, Descartes Locke, Descartes' Locke, Furthermore Locke, Ideas Descartes, Descartes' Locke's, Nevertheless Descartes, innate ideas, ideas innate, secondary qualities, innate disease, innate imprinted, innate knowledge, primary qualities, aristotelian theory, descartes vs locke, children idiots, Harcourt Inc, California Press, ideas ideas, Stich Stephen, outside sense perception, innate imprinted mind, vs locke debate, innate ideas innate,
Approximate Word count = 2580
Approximate Pages = 10 (250 words per page double spaced)
|
