The first of these men was a rich, older man by the name of Cephalus. He believed that justice meant speaking the truth at all times and always paying back one's debts. Cephalus said that a just man should return whatever is owed to another without hesitation or concern and to always tell the truth no matter the consequences. This caused Socrates much confusion and, using his dialetic method, he prodded deeper into to Cephalus's meaning to try to come up with some truth. Socrates said that being just is not as easy as just tel

I think that many of the ways justice is explained in The Republic have good and bad points to them. It does, however, confuse me in the amount of detail and depth of meanings they speak of. I do not agree that always telling the truth and paying one's debts is a way to be just. My own belief of what being just is probaby most closely resembles Socrates's. I believe that being just is an internal matter that each individual must deal with themselves. I agree that it can be very difficult to do the right thing when the world around is pulling us in so many different directions.

ling the truth and paying one's debts all the time. These actions could be considered just or unjust depending on the circumstances. If someone had borrowed his friend's whiskey and his friend, who is a recovering alcoholic, asked for it back, would it be the just thing to do to return it knowing his friend has a drinking problem or to keep it in order to help him out? That is the kind of question that Socrates posed to Cephalus to which he agreed and left the argument to his son, Polemarchus. Still, Polemarchus carried on the belief that "it is just to give to each what is owed" (331 e). However, he also states that it can depend on the circumstances around that situation specifically that one does whatever benefits their friends and harms thei

Some common words found in the essay are:
Polemarchus Polemarchus, Republic Plato, one's debts, enemies socrates, paying one's, believed justice, paying one's debts, telling truth paying, harming enemies socrates, truth paying one's, justice meant, truth paying, telling truth, soul justice, harming enemies,
Approximate Word count = 902
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)