Great Gatsby: Film vs Book
The Great Gatsby: The Film vs. The Book Before the invention of television and film the art of story telling was restricted to theater and literature. Theater was and still is performed live by actors who tell some kind of story through their performance. But theater is still limited greatly in its ability to convey setting to the viewer. In order to fully grasp the power of any story one must believe, in a sense, that the events are happening before them. Literature is better able to accomplish this by utilizing the power of the human imagination. Even more than this literature has the ability to describe human emotion through the use of strong metaphors and colorful language. It is this technique of writing that remains unique to literature. Even film cannot approach the human emotion and heart that literature has given people over the ages. Yet film is not without advantages of its own. Film can have strong power behind it. A kind of power that a viewer is forced to see and feel. This power is deliver! ed though a film's soundtrack, it's quick pace, and in recent years, the use of special effects. Good books are often made into films. Which is better? The answer to that question depends on the intentions of the
t of the film. The book cannot compare to the shock given to the viewer in the film. At this point the film has the advantage. In a following scene Gatsby is waiting discretely to make sure Tom does not take anger out on Daisy over the day's events. After Carraway checks to make sure everything is okay he tells Gatsby this is so yet Gatsby refuses to leave even though there is no danger to Daisy. The book describes the emotion of this scene very well, "[Gatsby] put his hands in his coat pockets and turned back eagerly to his scrutiny of the house, as though my presence marred the sacredness of the vigil," (p 153). This tells the reader that Gatsby is not staying around the house because he fears for Daisy's safety. There is something more human here and the literature is able to communicate this more efficiently than the film. Again, the author intended the book to surround the mystery of Gatsby's unique character and therefore the book again has the advantage. Fitzgerald, F. Scott "The Great Gatsby" . Rather than say that a character is in distress over something symbolism is used to give the reader something that most people can relate to so that they can identify with the hardship facing the character. Literature will always be able to offer emotion and passion more powerfully than film. Film is not without its own virtues, however. People rely on vision more than any other sense and to see something magnificent in person is far better than reading about it. Mel Gibson's "Braveheart" told a story of Scottish rebels fighting against their English oppressors. Reading a story of massive battles is of no comparison to seeing hundreds of people on a big screen battling for freedom and life. Add a powerful and moving soundtrack and this film is superior to any book telling a similar story. Then there are books that deal with normal life situations that can be easily told through both literature and film. In this case, as it is with The Great Gatsby, the intentions o! Another important scene in the story is where Mrs. Wilson is accidentally run down my Daisy. This is a pivotal point in the book because it brings two conflicts together: Tom Buchanan's affair with Mrs. Wilson (and subsequently Mr. Wilson's hatred of him) and Gatsby's interference in the marriage of Tom and Daisy. The importance of this conflict is amplified by the descriptive violent nature in which Mrs. Wilson dies. The book offers no light description, "they saw that her left breast was swinging loose like a flap and there was no need to listen for her heart beneath," (p 145). But the film gives the viewer an even more intense represe
Some common words found in the essay are:
Nick Carraway, Gatsby Film, Carraway Gatsby's, Tom Daisy, Gatsby Gatsby, Gibson's Braveheart, Gatsby Wilson, Morrison's Beloved, Odyssey Steinbeck, Scott Fitzgerald, person narrative, book translated film, book translated, translated film, film film, literature able, advantage scene, gatsby unique, gatsby action, action book, intended book, gatsby action book,
Approximate Word count = 1782
Approximate Pages = 7 (250 words per page double spaced)
|