Miss Jean Brodie/Dead Poet Society Comparison Essay

A detailed Summary of Miss Jean Brodie/Dead Poet Society Comparison Essay

Miss Jean Brodie/ Dead Poet Society Comparison Essay

Pressure is a ubiquitous force that touches everything, and can be as gentle as a whisper or as potent as the torrential grinding of an earthquake. In small calibrated amounts, we hardly notice it, yet when we consider the violent, compelling force it can awaken, the diamond is born from the rough. The eons of constant stress will bring out the full potential in the rock that was never considered to be there, in a similar way that pressure acts on human emotion. Virulent strain can push the human being to an extreme so shocking that it's difficult to imagine, and sometimes the consequences are permanent. When you compare the Dead Poet Society and the Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, pressure conflicts a student that the iconoclast teacher manipulates to pursue their past endeavors by proxy. The teacher and opposing force catch the adolescent in the middle, torn between what is expected of them and what the innermost desires of the student long for. At the apex of their unrelenting stress, they both tragically falter in their own form of death. The stress coagulates to a point that will furnish the diamond, but the excess stifles its shine. Opposing forces will sometimes bring ou

Instead of rising to meet the bar, Sandy and Neil both fall short in their deaths because of the pressure. By proxy, both teachers raise the students to a euphoria of hope to become themselves in a society where they've always followed the same guidelines, but it ultimately lead to their death. As they both are caught in the current of opposing viewpoints, Neil and Sandy make choices on what is best to overcome the pressure they face. Ironically, Sandy "dies" from a lack of pressure to guide her to what is right, after she goes to the other extreme to become a nun. Neil simply cannot cope with his decision to be an actor and the consequences his dad impinges on him for it, taking his own life to solve the stress. The rock tumbles and is fixated at the peak of its durability, creating the rare diamond. The society holds no mercy against the hope-filled student, creating a nun and a dead teenager.

In both the book and movie, Sandy and Neil have a goal to satisfy, but great differences in their supporting environments stop them. Stress is the constant comparison that affects both leading adoelescents, but they do carry some variety. The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie shows how inbalance will lead to destruction, where nothing is morally good, and Sandy's final choice is to repent for all the lack of virtue she once succumbed under. Miss Brodie, the symbol of unethical teaching, says this upon hearing that her creme de la creme student has joined a convent; "what a waste. That is not the sort of dedication I meant" (Spark 93). To make matters worse, Sandy's idol of religious purity, Mr. Lloyd, delves into the reform that Miss Brodie puts upon the girls. At first, when he is shown to be a devoted father and Catholic, Sandy clings to his sanctity and is attracted to his religious vocation to Chritianity, until of course he becomes an adulterer and a sinner. "...he kissed her long and wetly. He said in a hoarse voice, "That'll teach you to look at an artist like that" (Spark 150). Sandy then runs because her once beacon of hope had sunken into the abyss of sin, and the pressure of immorality pushed her to the edge. Consequently, she became a nun, trying to make up f

Some common words found in the essay are:
Jean Brodie, Catholic Sandy, Miss Brodie, John Keatting, Essay Pressure, Sandy Neil, Miss Brodie's, Ironically Sandy, Shulman Neil, Neil Neil's, miss brodie, poet society, dead poet, dead poet society, status quo, jean brodie, miss jean, sandy neil, prime miss jean, opposing force, shulman neil, john keatting, miss jean brodie,

Approximate Word count = 1465
Approximate Pages = 6 (250 words per page double spaced)

Category: English