Dyslexia: Causes and Contributors
A discussion of the causes and contributors to dyslexia must be, by necessity, a complex undertaking that deals with a myriad of controversial topics. Even the name breads controversy: what exactly is dyslexia? Is it the same as specific learning difficulties? Can it be defined as a single condition? Is there a continuum of dyslexic type difficulties? Should we be using a label at all? The questions raised are numerous, yet there are very few satisfactory answers. It is therefore necessary to begin with a working definition of dyslexia, to gain an understanding of dyslexia before we discuss it in any detail. After this definition has been made the believed causes (grouped into the following categories: genetic, perceptual, neurological and linguistic) will be looked at in some depth, which will precede a thorough evaluation of the evidence. It will be found that, as yet, no single cause can be definitively established, but that studies into information and language processing in the brain seem to offer the most promising possibilities for the future.As previously stated, because the term dyslexia covers a wide variety of topics it is almost impossible to find a definition which adequately covers all relevant issues and is able
Jorm (1983), The psychology of reading and spelling disabilities, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul There is greater agreement in the area of phonological awareness, i.e. the ability to perceive that words are made up of a combination of sounds (phonemes) to produce words and can be represented by written symbols (or graphemes) in English. McBride (1995) states three components of PA - verbal short term memory, speech perception and intelligence. The beginning of awareness is the ability firstly to divide the speech stream into words, and then segment the words into phonemes. Ellis, H. & Miles, L.E. (1981) in Snowling (1987), Dyslexia - a cognitive developmental approach, Oxford: Blackwell Galaburda, A.M., & Kemper (1981) in Hornsby (1992), Overcoming dyslexia, London: Optima The question of genetics has long been linked to dyslexia, or "congenital word blindness" as Hinshelwood, Morgan and Kerr named it in 1900 after studying the incidences of intelligent people who could not read, and who were related, founding the idea that dyslexia is partly geneticall y determined (see Huston, 1987). This initial research into the relationship of genetics to dyslexia has been followed by a number of scientific research and personal observation reports through the past one hundred years. In 1976 Finucci found that in 45% of cases, immediate family members of the dyslexic person exhibited the same traits, confirming the belief that dyslexia runs in families. While in 1992, Dr B. Hornsby made the observation that 88% of the children treated by her had a family history of dyslexia. These studies and observations can be criticised for their lack of accounting for an environmental explanation (i.e. if one or both parents do not read well, then it could be argued that their children through a lack of parental modelling and guidance could "inherit" the same difficulties). Recent studies have attempted to overcome this flaw in genetic theory by using twin studies, which allow comparison between monozygotic twins (genes 100% the same) and dizygotic twins (50% the same), with the specification that these twins were brought up together to cancel any environmental discrepancies. Using this method Herman (1959) and Jorm (1983) found that a 100% concordance for monozygotic twins and a 33% concordance for dizygotic twins, suggesting a role for genetic factors. Cardon, Smith, Fulker, Kimberling, Pennington and De Fries (1994), and Grigorenko (1997) go even further in their research to suggest that dyslexia is controlled by chromosome six. However this does not explain how new instances of dyslexia occur in families without and past history or why not everyone in a family with dyslexic history has this condition. The only reliable conclusion that can be drawn, is that genetics appear to play a part in the causation of dyslexia, but they cannot fully explain it. A combination of factors, need to exist for dyslexia to manifest itself. Miles, L.E. (1974) in Hornsby (1992), Overcoming dyslexia, London: Optima
Some common words found in the essay are:
Vellutino Scanlon, Bryant Bradley, Galaburda Kemper, , Thomson Watkins, Critchley Critchley, Dr Hornsby, De Fries, Morgan Kerr, Ellis Miles, snowling 1987, oxford blackwell, dyslexia cognitive, snowling 1987 dyslexia, developmental approach oxford, developmental approach, cognitive developmental, 1987 dyslexia, hornsby 1992, approach oxford blackwell, bradley 1985, cognitive developmental approach, approach oxford, dyslexia cognitive developmental, bryant bradley,
Approximate Word count = 2863
Approximate Pages = 11 (250 words per page double spaced)
|