Psychoanalytic theory vs behaviourism: motivation
Freud's psychoanalytic theory with its model of the mind and its central concepts provides a better interpretation of one's behavior and accounts for behavior on a wider scope of issues than does the radical behaviorist theory of B. F. Skinner. Skinner successfully explains human behavior in terms of operant conditioning and reinforcing agents. He changes the focus from Freud's internalized (mental) processes to the importance of the external environment. Skinner emphasizes the importance of the directly observable behavior. However, he fails to completely account for behavior, excluding the original motivational drive. In contrast, Freud succeeds in construing the origins of behavior and motivation, which makes the psychoanalytic theory of Freud more adequate as a theory of personality. Throughout history humans have been puzzled by human behavior, the reasons behind it, and have been faced with the consequences of their own as well as others' behavior. Many studies have been done and theories developed in an attempt to explain this fascinating area of human existence. Among many theories and theorists, Freud's psychoanalytic and Skinner's radical behaviorist theories have bee
Psychoanalysis does account for issues such as these and is, therefore, more adequate in explaining behavior than radical behaviorism is. The reason it is important to study and interpret the behavior in light of operant conditioning is because it is the behavior which has been selected as a crucial element with survival value (Skinner, 1974). Skinner was a radical behaviorist who felt that questions about memories, anxiety, intelligence and emotions should have never been asked in the field of psychology; that psychology should limit itself to studies of accessible subject matter (Skinner, 1987). He did not deny the possibility of the existence of the unconscious and the existence consciousness, but rather put them aside in favor of studying directly observable behavior (Skinner, 1974) saying that "human thought is human behavior" and that the mental processes are essentially "what people have said and done" (Skinner, 1974: p 117).
Some common words found in the essay are:
Freud's Skinner's, According Skinner, Skinner Skinner, Freud Freud, , radical behaviorism, skinner 1974, freud 1984, freud 1936, psychoanalytic theory, id impulse, skinner 1987, operant conditioning, original motivational, reality principle, behavior skinner 1974, freud 1936 ego, original motivational drive, directly observable behavior, operant conditioning behavior,
Approximate Word count = 2478
Approximate Pages = 10 (250 words per page double spaced)
|