Nature vs. Progress

A detailed Summary of Nature vs. Progress


In their articles °Hetch Hetchy± and °A Statement of San Francisco¯s Side of the Hetch-Hetchy Reservoir Matter± John Muir and Marsden Manson are on opposing sides of a debate of nature versus progress. The Hetch Hetchy area being discussed was once a beautiful landscape neighboring Yosemite Park that had many of the same features that made Yosemite a national treasure. Both authors use a similar article structure in that they are weighing the pros and cons of developing the Hetch Hetchy area. A brief examination of their articles will show that Muir¯s article deals more with nature, whereas Manson¯s deals with a city¯s benefit.

It is clear that from Muir¯s essay that he loves nature and the wilderness and that Hetch Hetchy is one of his favorite places to go. He gives great detail of the trees, rock formations,


waterfalls, and many other aspects of the land. He believes Hetch Hetchy should not be destroyed and gives several debating points. First, he mentions that the beautiful landscape of the valley floor would be destroyed if the valley were flooded. In his description of the valley floor, Muir describes that is even more beautiful than neighboring Yosemite valley. Secondly, he mentions that the city has other resources of water that can be used instead of flooding the valley. Muir explains that San Francisco has plenty of water in its other reservoirs, such as Lake Eleanor. Also, Muir mentions that camping up stream from the reservoir would make the water not suitable for drinking. Finally, Muir talks about how all the campers that visit the valley would not have a place to go anymore. Being a great lover of the

Some common words found in the essay are:
Hetch Hetchy, Muir Manson, San Francisco, Finally Manson, Finally Muir, Yosemite Park, Eleanor Muir, Marsden Manson, , hetch hetchy, Marsden Mansen¯s, nature versus progress, beautiful landscape, nature versus, versus progress, san francisco, neighboring yosemite, rock formations, debate nature, valley floor, debate nature versus,

Approximate Word count = 552
Approximate Pages = 2 (250 words per page double spaced)

Category: Miscellaneous

join now Save Paper

Related Essays

  • Nature Vs. Nurture ... The nature vs. ... Until we realize that nature and nurture are one entity that must be utilized in order for the human race to progress, nature will run its ... 3696 words
  • Karl Poper vs Thomas Kuhn KARL POPPER vs. ... can be defined as knowledge and theory on the nature and operation ... question of that discussion is whether there is scientific progress or not. ... 1746 words
  • Kuhn vs. Popper ... progress that science made possible refutes Kuhnamp39s view that science does not progress toward a more accurate representations of the workings of nature. ... 1129 words
  • Idealization vs. Demonization ... various tribes as doomed to be destroyed by European progress and civilization ... European civilization in the corresponded Native Americans with nature that was ... 921 words
  • Biomedical Dilemmas Science vs. Religion ... ampquotAdvances in the field of genetic engineering could mean progress on an ... They are firmly convinced that this human intervention into nature is unethical, and ... 1759 words

Professional Essays

  • Homosexuality as Nature or Nurture ... Bermant calls the nature vs. nurture debate a trap that bars scientific progress in terms of attaining a full understanding how the biophysical works with the ... 1640 words
  • Academics vs. Athletics: Is Reform Possible Academics vs. ... was responsible for drawing attention to the widespread nature of brutality ... such efforts at reform, few believe that much progress has occurred in ... 1282 words
  • Academics vs. Athletics: Is Reform Possible Academics vs. ... was responsible for drawing attention to the widespread nature of brutality ... such efforts at reform, few believe that much progress has occurred in ... 1282 words
  • Bahrain ampamp Egypt BAHRAIN VS EGYPT Hist ... While Egypt made some social and economic progress, Egyptamp39s devastating defeat by ... Given the fractious nature of Egyptian politics, the government is torn ... 2500 words
  • CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT VS. WOMENamp39S RIGHTS MOVEMENT CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT VS. ... 18601870 This research paper discusses the nature and course of ... Such progress as was achieved in securing political rights for the ... 7476 words
  • Competition Vs. Cooperation among Military Women ... to women in organizations, Duckworth observes that, while most women by nature favour collaboration ... Progress in experimental personality research. ... Women vs. ... 3602 words


Saved Paper

Save your papers so you can locate them quickly!

Newest Essays

Testimonials

  • "Thank You So Much!!! You have saved me once again!!!"
    Jack M.
  • "With so many papers to chose from, I was able to get ideas to help me with all of my classes. Thank You!"
    Brian P.
  • "I've used this site for the last 3 years to help me come up with ideas for my papers."
    Sara J.
  • "I use this site every week to help me write my own papers!"
    Rachel W.
  • "I love this site!!!"
    Marie N.
Home Join Now Support
Acceptable Use Policy About us FAQ
All papers are for research and reference purposes only!
© 2002-2009 DirectEssays.com. All Rights Reserved.