The question of whether it is right to have random drug testing in public schools or not is a very controversial issue. The main issues with this is whether or not it is an invasion of privacy or an issue of unreasonable search and seizure. In school the students have enough stress and other things that are going on to worry about random drug tests. The money this would cost could be put to many other places in the education department. The idea of random drug testing in public schools is an outrageous and foolish notion in my opinion.
One of the most important issues with the question of drug testing in public schools is if it's an invasion of privacy or not. To most people this would be a clear case of invasion of privacy. The question of whether or not a student is taking any type of illegal drug should be the responsibility of the students parents or guardian, not the schools. The only exception that I could see would be if there was a case where they thought that the student was having erratic or dangerous behavior. Students at public schools these days already feel like they don't have any privacy with cameras in classrooms and buses and the arrival of more cops. Adding drug testing to these other factors wo
Another important question would be which does more harm: the drugs or the testing. If a student is doing an illegal drug and they have a drug test and get kicked out of school, yet the student was making good grades and showed up for class every day eager to learn. Which one did more harm in that situation? It seems to me that random testing in schools would just harm the students more then help them, if there out of class taking a urine test then they are missing important learning time in class. In other cases it could also help say there was a student selling drugs to other students if they take a drug test and fail then they get kicked out of school you have eliminated the source of the problem. I guess it just depends on how you look at the situation and the different pros and cons of each side of the argument.
Another key issue would be if random drug testing in public schools is a case of unreasonable search and seizure. It seems that it would clearly be a case of unreasonable search and seizure of every student at every school because they do not have any reason to suspect that students are doing any type of illegal drug. I mean what reason could you possibly have in giving a honor roll student who is active in many different school activities a drug test, or the cheerleader who was the homecoming queen. In most case there wouldn't be any reason at all. The use of locker searches at school is probably already a close call on whether or not its unreasonable search or not the only difference is that the schools are searching their property, but with
All papers and essays are for research and reference purposes only!
Copyright 2002-2009
Direct Essays , LLC. All Rights Reserved. DMCA Webmasters make $$$$