For years, historians had been writing that the American Revolution was the virtuous reaction to England's curtailment of rights. Then, in 1967, Harvard history professor Bernard Bailyn added his additional theory of ideology. In his book, The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution, Bailyn agreed that the settlers were principled. Yet that was not the main cause of the discontent. Instead, he said, the settlers had inherited the suspicion of dangers that lurked with power of one entity over another. Rather than seeing England's actions as solely unintended slipups, the colonists were paranoid enough to read them as part of a political plot. Obsession, not principles, led to the revolution.
Four decades later, no one is surprised that Bailyn comes up with a different twist to history. "For the last five decades Bernard Bailyn has been the preeminent colonial American historian"1. According to Professor Richard Beeman of the University of Pennsylvania, he has been more influential understanding "the content and cultural dynamic of American history than any other historian of the past half century.2.
Bailyn truly believes the saying, "learn by history." To President Bill Clinton and other guests at the 2000 White House Millennium Council, reprinted on the website, he stated, "in our public life we Americans, though we are often described as a young nation, with a shallow history, in fact live remarkably close to our past, and I mean the deeper past, reaching back 400 years to the first settlements of Europeans on mainland North America and 200 years to the founding of the nation."3 Every day, the past and present are interrelated. For example, he added, are the Federalist Papers of over 200 years ago, "Yet we study every phrase of these essays for meanings relevant to our present public life. The Supreme Court refers to their authority repeatedly 34 times between 1981 and 1985 in decisions that affect the lives of every American in the late 20th century.
Continue reading this essay Continue reading
Page 1 of 3